Power conversion system designers face a dilemma when selecting gate drive solutions for their power stages — fixed gate drive voltage solutions, while simple to implement, lack the flexibility to accommodate different transistor technology requirements. For instance, optimal gate voltages for
IGBTs, Si and
SiC MOSFETs vary, consequently requiring the use of gate drive circuits or a total power stage redesign for newer transistor generations.
IGBTs typically require a positive gate voltage between +15V and +20V to fully turn on. For rapid turn-off and false triggering prevention, IGBTs require a negative gate voltage between -5V and -15V. Si MOSFETs have lower gate voltage requirements in contrast, generally needing between +10V and +15V to turn on and between 0V and -5V to turn off. SiC MOSFETs, chosen for their high switching speeds and low on-state resistance, have gate voltages close to those of IGBTs — with some devices requiring up to +25V for optimal performance. Using fixed gate drive voltage solutions for multiple transistors can lead to suboptimal performance, increased loss, and failure due to insufficient or excessive gate voltages. Designers may consequently resort to using separate gate drive circuits tailored to each transistor type, which increases not only the overall system complexity, but also cost and board space.
Increasing the switching frequency and voltage to enhance both efficiency and power density introduces certain challenges. Higher frequencies require faster switching transitions, which can result in increased EMI and noise issues. Faster switching edges (high dv/dt and di/dt) can couple noise through the circuit’s parasitic capacitances, including the transistor package, PCB traces, and isolation barriers. This noise interferes with the gate drive circuit’s proper operation, leading to unintended switching and even increased power loss and device failure.
Using high-performance components to achieve faster switching comes at a premium, as designers must strike a balance between cost and performance based on the application and market requirements. For example, designers may opt for lower-cost Si MOSFETs or IGBTs in cost-sensitive consumer applications. This decision sacrifices efficiency and performance in favor of a cheaper solution. On the other hand, in high-performance
industrial or
automotive applications, using expensive SiC MOSFETs may be justified to achieve efficiency, reliability, and power density benchmarks.
The need to reduce overall system size is another significant challenge in power stage design. As power density becomes increasingly important, designers must find ways to achieve greater miniaturization and seamlessly integrate gate drive circuitry without compromising performance or reliability. Unfortunately, standard gate drive solutions rely on discrete components and separate power supplies, which can occupy valuable board space and complicate the design. Discrete gate drive circuits consist of the following: a gate drive IC, isolated power supply, passive components such as resistors, capacitors, diodes, and more. Carefully selecting and placing each component on the PCB can only be done after considering factors such as power dissipation, thermal management, and signal integrity. As the number of transistors in a power stage increases, so does gate drive circuitry complexity and size.